Outsider textual theory after Cage

Jane U. Varwig
Department of Ethnomusicology, Wesleyan College

Stefan Allen
Department of Sociolinguistics, Yale University

1. Expressions of newness

In the works of Bjork, a primary concept is the defining of proto-cultural performance. This idea has precedent: Why might, or indeed should, truth fulfill the critic, conversely constrained by a material modernist outsider textual theory? It could be said that Adorno's analysis of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation implies that performance is intrinsically responsible for elitism, but only if Born's critique of encompassment is a challenge; if that is not the case, Marx's model of Cusickist power/pleasure/intimacy triad is one of "the "scientific" concept of listening", and hence problematic. Though homophobias reinforce masculine composition, the contributions of diverse actors rehear composition and sustain feminine composition, enriching outsider textual theory. (Rodin[1]) Hamilton[2] implies that we have to decide between textual narrative and textual narrative.

"Music is part of the dialectic of scholarship," writes Eco. But what does this really mean? In a larger sense, Derrida promotes the use of outsider textual theory to challenge the canon. For whom might, we would insist must, Boulez (completely seeking only to escape experimentalist so-called semiotic post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation) entrench, even "negate", open work? The response is unmistakable. E.g., Eco uses the term "post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation" to denote the mediation between physicality and society. (The participant has a choice: either accept Cheng's analysis of outsider textual theory and rightly accept that art is history or, on the contrary, accept Burney's essay on outsider textual theory.)

Though Bloom is known for believing, "language is fundamentally used in the service of the musicologist," the writings of Katz[3] show that in a way, language is not fundamentally used in the service of the musicologist, but it is instead the collapse, and eventually the collapse, of language that is fundamentally used in the service of the musicologist. The premise of outsider textual theory states that the Conservatory is capable of truth. The thesis characterizing the works of Adorno is a romantic whole. Thus narrative's feeling of ambiguity, and insistence on respelling the society prevalent in ambiguity, reiterates textual narrative. Hence the subject is contextualized into a post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation that merges politics with a totality. But several theories relating to "Schenkerian" composition cannot exist, and each of which can be indexed in turn.

However, the economy, or rather paradigm, is also evident in measures 250-270 of Oliveros's Sonic Meditations, albeit in a self-repeating mode throughout bars 51-80 and 147-167. In the places where archaic, elitist elitist perceptions of musics attempt to reinforce white, male culture, ethnomusicological approaches rehear culture and find success in empowering queer culture, amplifying popular music. If outsider textual theory is true, the works of Adorno are empowering. My auto-ethnographical publications concerning post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation suggest a linguistics of identity in the Wagnerian-proto-improvisationist vein. The Haupttema of the works of Adorno is the role of the composer as composer/observer. Yet could textual narrative privilege super-cultural canon, similarly completely seeking only to escape experimentalist so-called semiotic post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation?

Trippett[4] holds that we have to choose between outsider textual theory and post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation. (The improviser has a dilemma: one can accept Barraque's monograph on textual narrative and reflexively reject that sexuality, perhaps ironically, has undertones of real worth, but only if outsider textual theory is uncertain; otherwise, society has to have intrinsic meaning, given that performance vis-a-vis scholarship is interchangeable with memory or one can accept Abbate's model of textual narrative.) Solomon promotes the use of textual narrative to read around the canon. In a sense, analysis's entrenching of ambiguity espouses sonorousist neo-cultural theory.

Nevertheless how should the stage--completely hampered by a semiotic pre-romantic post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation--situate, one could assert modify, the Other? However, the premise of outsider textual theory implies that narrative comes from the performer. Therefore as an example, Solomon uses the term "liberal minimalism" to denote the dialectic, and some would say the genius, of romanticist music. The failure, or rather modulation, quotes mm. 41-52 of Bjork's Bachelorette, albeit in a more redundant sense in measures 135-165, 294-313, and hinted at in 296-318, and, earlier, paradoxically in the compositions of Haydn.

It could be said that the individual is decoupled into a textual narrative that merges musical form with a worth system. Many compositions about both theory and de-theory exist, each Wright analyses in turn [5]. Ergo, my previous discoveries relating to post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation revealed that a statement like "the task of the (ethno-)musicologist-analyst is progression" cannot be discovered (distinct from Abbateist voicelessness). In "the Fifth Symphony," Mahler denies Da-sein; in "the Fourth Symphony", though, he alters his stance totally, turning an eye to outsider textual theory. The characteristic theme of Owens's[6] critique of textual narrative is the transition between physicality and disability.

2. Cage remanifested

If one confronts cultural ambiguity, one is faced with a choice: (a) accept post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation, or, on the other hand, (b) decide that truth is capable of progression. Though status quos reinforce conservative history, the contributions of multicultural thinkers attack history and enrich liberal history, amplifying outsider textual theory. (Wegman[7]) (If textual narrative be true, we have to pick between outsider textual theory and textual performance.) When might, and better must, Cusick (standing up to a bimusicalist post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation) propagate textual narrative? For the reply, one turns to McClary (1950: 241-260). It could be said that Adorno promotes the use of outsider textual theory to challenge art.

Kramer's essay on post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation suggests that composition serves to reinforce elitism. In a larger sense, the subject is restated into a textual narrative that subsumes language under a paradox. It could be said that the orchestra's deconstructing of music, and insistence instead on reinventing the society intrinsic to music, espouses proto-minimalist canon.

The musicologist has a paradox: either accept Born's model of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation and subsequently accept that culture has significance, given that McClary's analysis of feminism is to be believed or reject Beach's critique of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation. Adorno uses the term "outsider textual theory" to denote the absurdity, and subsequent form, of "scientific" music. Cusick suggests the use of Ecoist open form to problematize sexism.

3. Performances of defining characteristic

In the works of McClary, an important concept is the defining of inter-semiotic politics vis-a-vis performance. In a sense, an abundance of proto-structuralisms concerning the bridge between sexuality and society are, paradoxically, revealed. (The futility, or as some might say romantic pigeonholing, can be observed in bars 257-271 of Saariaho's Nymphea in mm. 20-47, 219-230, and paraphrased in 195-223.) "Feminine Endings" affirms atonality where Ross's "articles for the New Yorker" reiterates atonality. The primary thesis of Clemmens's[8] monograph on textual narrative is a self-supporting entity. But my prior investigations about outsider textual theory promote a discipline of new perspectives in the Brettian-theoryist mode (the Lockwoodist notions of this outburst are absurd).

"Ambiguity is scholarship," says Cheng. The concert hall's hearing of music enforces the "modern" concept(s) of composition. Fitzpatrick[9] states that we have to choose between post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation and post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation. However, the premise of meta-textual minor theory holds that academe is part of the sensitivity of musical form, but only if memory is equal to history. But why can ethnomusicology respell, and/or some would insist conflate, art?

The idea of the works of McClary is not composition, but trans-composition. Although outmoded, conservative modes of exclusions try to entrench neoliberal truth, subcultures read past truth and find success in upholding postmodern truth, bolstering the disabled. The artist is situated into a textual narrative that includes musical form as a totality. In a sense, the obligation of outsider textual theory depicted in McClary's "Modal Endings" is also evident in "The Magic Mountain", albeit in a romantic mode. E.g., Cheng uses the term "post-romanticist narrative" to denote the role of the critic/composer as participant.

Adorno suggests the use of outsider textual theory to read disability. Many sites for ambiguities about Wagnerist Gesamtkunstwerk cannot exist, every one Slim reenacts individually [10]. (The listener has a choice: one can accept Nietzsche's model of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation or, subversively, one can reject Riemann's critique of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation and rightly accept that expression is a product of notated music.) Hence Randel[11] states that we have to decide between textual narrative and outsider textual theory.

It could be said that the newness can be observed in bars 283-289 of Wagner's Rheingold, though in a more self-denying sense, and further throughout mm. 217-234 and 215-216 (and, earlier, in embryonic form throughout the compositions of Debussy). In a sense, the focus of Dorf's[12] analysis of textual narrative is neither prolongation, nor sub-prolongation, but rather so-called prolongation. My prior publications about post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation uncovered that a statement like "the purpose of the musicologist is mere masturbation" cannot be found. Nevertheless when should outsider textual theory, constrained by the feminist textual narrative, negate and even "transgress" the analyst (itself perhaps surprisingly trapped by ambiguous super-triadicist performance)? A pre-cultural material response is given in Sherr's "Competence and Incompetence".

Though hierarchies entrench straight composition, the contributions of gay studies rehear composition and sustain queer composition, advancing neo-"cryptographic" romantic theory. (Stone[13]) In a larger sense, the stage's decoding of music, and insistence rather on silencing the use of narrative in music, contrasts, some might write espouses, post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation. Abbate's essay on outsider textual theory implies that politics is capable of intentionality. The object is contextualized into a textual narrative that includes language vis-a-vis culture as a whole.

For instance, Wagner uses the term "hermeneutic self-composition" to denote not proto-construction, but post-proto-construction. Therefore Heidegger promotes the use of post-cryptographicist proto-appropriation to attack globalization. But the example of gender study which is a central argument of Shaw's "Partita" emerges further in "Partita" (contra Sisman [14]). (A number of compositions relating to the common ground between society and music are discovered, and each could be reframed individually.)

4. Outsider textual theory and nationalist postmodernism

"We must challenge sexuality before we amplify sexuality." So wrote Tomlinson in the preface of "The Singing of The New World: Indigenous Voice"--not to argue we shouldn't promote them. Yet why must Ueno decouple, better respell, homophobia? However, if textual narrative is false, we have to choose between nationalist postmodernism and textual narrative. It could be said that the performer per se has a choice: either reject Feldman's model of outsider textual theory or, alternatively, accept Bloom's critique of outsider textual theory. My personal discoveries concerning nationalist postmodernism suggest a music theory of new perspectives in the Solomonian-narrativeist style. This economy, or rather paradigm, quotes measures 273-299 of Muhly's I Drink the Air Before Me (taking its surroundings into account) in mm. 31-59, 33-62, and (in retrograde) in 89-93, and throughout many works of Berlioz.

The meta-textual ideal of narrative suggests that listening is a product of our worth-system. Marx promotes the use of romantic theory to problematize the critic. The object is restated into a textual narrative that encompasses ambiguity within a paradox. (The principal idea of Peattie's[15] monograph on outsider textual theory is the common ground between art and music.) Ergo, any number of sexualisms about nationalist postmodernism may be revealed.

Therefore although fixed musicologists attempt to reinforce white, cis-male, heterosexual memory, interdisciplinary scholars read through memory and flourish in foregrounding Global memory, empowering the Other. In a sense, in "String Quartets," Shaw condemns Marxist sonorousist theory; in "String Quartets", however, she examines outsider textual theory. In a larger sense, for instance, Marx uses the term "textual narrative" to denote the futility, and thus the collapse, of proto-cultural performance. But for whom should, or we can insist would, uncritical ambiguity--ironically standing up to a "scientific" proto-appropriation--entrench popular culture?

At last, it is clear that the relationships among outsider textual theory, textual narrative, and nationalist postmodernism (to say nothing of the "ecomusicological" concepts of context, which we have barely had space to touch upon) are evolving towards a more capitalist end. Increased examination of Shaw's works, in particular Partita, in the context of Kramerist other-voicedness and the musician-(ethno-)musicologist's all-too-Schenkerian performance will be the window to prolongation.

1. Rodin, Z. (1936) Cage, post-romanticism, and outsider textual theory. Indiana University Press

2. Hamilton, Catherine ed. (1974) Triads/Dyads: Outsider textual theory in the writings of Solie. University of Michigan Press

3. Katz, T. F. (2011) Textual narrative in the works of Adorno. Oxford University Press

4. Trippett, Barbara ed./trans. (1978) Contexts of Stasis: Outsider textual theory, post-romanticism, and "scientific" modernist theory. McGraw Hill

5. Wright, Q. (1983) Outsider textual theory in the works of Mahler. University of California, Berkeley Press

6. Owens, Susan (1892) Quasi"conceptual" Self-appropriations: Outsider textual theory in the writings of McClary. Indiana University Press

7. Wegman, I. A. W. ed./trans. (1968) Textual narrative without outsider textual theory. Grinnell University Press

8. Clemmens, Rene ed. (2001) Analyzing Feminism: Outsider textual theory and textual narrative. Edward Mellyn Press

9. Fitzpatrick, H. ed./trans. (1989) Post-romanticism, cultural modernism, and outsider textual theory. M.I.T. Press

10. Slim, Matthias (1994) Contextualizing, reinforcing, and reinventing: Outsider textual theory after Mockus. Scarecrow Press

11. Randel, Ll. (2012) Textual narrative in the music of Beethoven. University of Michigan Press

12. Dorf, Emily ed. (1877) Outsider textual theory in the music of Shaw. Wesleyan University Press

13. Stone, O. (2015) The Failure of Physicality: Outsider textual theory in the music of Zorn. McGraw Hill

14. Sisman, Gina ed./trans. (1988) The Forbidden Sea: Outsider textual theory and textual narrative. W.W. Norton

15. Peattie, Y. (1996) Outsider textual theory in the works of Straus. Yale University Press

Automatic bad new musicology paper generator: based on the Postmodernist essay generator and the Dada engine.


In the further interest of self-parody, I am starting work on an Old Musicology random essay generator; please email me with ideas. All I know is that every paper will begin "On f. 3v, a new watermark ..." etc.